Independent thoughts (I’m no party animal)

Groucho is still one of my all-time favorites. I still don’t know how that elephant got in his pajamas …
Image found on Wikimedia Commons.

Groucho Marx famously resigned from the Friars Club with the explanation that he didn’t want to belong to any club that would have him as a member.

A plurality of Americans must feel the same way as, at last count, 43 percent polled by Gallup classified themselves as independent, compared with 27 percent identifying as Republican and 29 percent as Democrats. That breakdown has been pretty consistent over the years. The last time I found with one of the major parties taking the lead was a week in December 2012 when 38 percent identified as Democrat, 35 percent as independent, and 25 percent as Republican. With leaners, it tends to be about evenly split.

What could I possibly add?
Image found on me.me.

I often wonder why anyone would associate with any party, much less one that stresses ideological purity (what’s next, genetic purity?). Such a belief places little faith in what voters would do with their free will when given all the information needed on a given issue, instead insisting that if you’re X party, you must vote for X policy.

You vill do vhat you are told.

I’ve never been able to understand straight-line voting; it implies that people are unable to think for themselves. Surely that’s not right. No one needs talking points to communicate, do they? (That’s sarcasm, folks; apparently some do.) Besides, thinking is for those elite idjits. It’s so much easier when you can just believe liberalism or conservatism is a mental disorder and attack the other side accordingly. (If you ever want to lose faith in humanity, take a look at forums of the like-minded, like Guns & Ammo, various subreddits, Free Republic and Democratic Underground.)

If the sniping were this entertaining, I might be able to stand it.
GIF found on imgur.

One of the biggest reasons for people becoming independent voters is because they’re sick of all the partisan sniping. When even your choice of restaurant can paint you in a partisan light, I can hardly blame them. Politics aren’t the reason I don’t go to Chick-fil-A; pickles are … they have no place on a chicken sandwich as far as I’m concerned. I don’t even put them on my chicken burgers. Oh, Lord, and now KFC is apparently doing a pickle fried chicken sandwich. If God had intended pickles to be combined with chicken, he would have created cucumber-flavored chickens.

Ew. Just ew.

Moist, pickle-juice-laden bun … yuck. And everything tastes like pickle!
Image found on Food in Real Life.

Sure, the politics of Chick-fil-A’s owners and those of Hobby Lobby and others give me pause, but their products are all I’m thinking about (yeah, I don’t like the waffle fries, either … they get too cold too quickly and need ketchup, which I don’t eat). The way things have been going, though, people will start ignoring the food served and instead make their restaurant decisions based on the owners’ politics. No clue yet what that would mean for people like me, but no spicy and/or greasy food, garlic or red meat for me, please; IBS is a cruel mistress. Yes, I occasionally break protocol (have to have fried catfish at least once a year), but I pay for it.

Founding fathers like George Washington and John Adams weren’t fans of partisan politics and warned against them, for all the good that did. The Federalists and Democratic-Republicans soon started making waves … and unfounded allegations against opponents. And it’s only gotten worse.

Maybe if Congress would have snowball fights like this one between pages in 1923, they’d loosen up and work together. But I don’t trust this lot today not to use rocks.
Image found on Ghosts of DC.

Working together for the greater good? Pshaw! It’s much more fun to dig in and refuse to negotiate, so if you don’t have the majority, well, you’re just out of luck. This is heightened by “negative partisanship,” where you’re loyal to your party just because you don’t like the other party.

Hey, it’s not their fault their mamas dress them funny! All right, maybe a little of it is. Their mamas wouldn’t keep buying those lederhosen if someone spoke up.

In general, I tend to trust independent thinkers far more than party animals because they seem to be more likely to give facts greater import than partisanship when making a decision. Those on the left and right, especially on the fringes, are far more likely to base decisions on party loyalty.

Jim Geraghty, National Review senior political correspondent, wrote back in the heat of the 2016 race of this scary partisan devotion becoming, essentially, a religion.

Pretty much every day at my job with certain letter-writers. Sigh.
Editorial cartoon by Dan Wasserman, Boston Globe.

“Ultimately,” he wrote, “what far too many people in politics believe is that the other party is just the bad guys, the embodiment of all flaws of human nature and every kind of sin, to be defeated at all costs. Period. The exact same traits are interpreted completely differently based upon partisan affiliation. The other side is greedy, selfish, and miserly; my side is thrifty and determined to avoid waste. Their side is dumb and can’t understand details; my side is focused on the big picture and doesn’t get bogged down in the weeds. The other side is a bunch of warmongers; my side won’t compromise on protecting innocent lives. The other side is a bunch of simple-minded jingoist nationalists; my side is a steel-spined band of patriots. Their side is a freak show, the worst of humanity, a “basket of deplorables”; my side has passionate grass roots with lovable eccentricities. Their side is incompetent; my side makes innocent, harmless mistakes.

It’s not even a real bone. It’s plastic. And squeaky.
Image found on Meme Castle.

“This is a really stupid way to look at the world. Human virtue does not line up by party. Each side is big enough to include some jerks, loons, maniacs, idiots, insufferable know-it-alls, pathological liars, and toxic personalities. To think otherwise, you have to spend a lot of time ignoring the counter-evidence while making your life a festival of confirmation bias.”

Oh, but it’s not confirmation bias unless you’re referring to the other party’s beliefs. For your own party it’s truth handed down from on high from God himself (or herself), packaged in a beautiful box of chocolates.

These look good. I hope there’s some orange cremes in there.
Image found on Wellington Chocolates.

Even if I was offered chocolate, it wouldn’t make me want to join a party. I can buy my own, and without any of that weird, tough nougat or fillings (ahem, crickets) that have no business being in chocolate. Who likes that stuff?

I’ll take orange, lemon and raspberry fillings, if you please, with the occasional chocolate mousse or coconut (and maybe pecans or almonds … protein, ya know). But no loonies or jerks. I have enough of those.

At one time the parties would at least pretend to get along. No more.
Image found on Progressive Army.

I minored in political science in college, but only had two professors in that department who wore their political affiliations on their sleeves. One let it affect grading; the other did not. I took three classes from the one that didn’t, as opposed to one from the one who did, and got an A in all four classes. I enjoyed going to class with the one who didn’t let politics get in the way (Dr. Richard Wang, an awesome professor) precisely because he encouraged debate, which was often spirited and occasionally hilarious.

That’s what’s missing in much of today’s politics. True debate isn’t happening because no one wants to entertain ideas other than the party line.

If it never enters my ear canal, I don’t have to consider it.
GIF found on gfycat.

Political scientist Lilliana Mason of the University of Maryland, author of Uncivil Agreement: How Politics Became Our Identity, last month told Perry Bacon Jr. of FiveThirtyEight: “A single vote can now indicate a person’s partisan preference as well as his or her religion, race, ethnicity, gender, neighborhood and favorite grocery store. This is no longer a single social identity. … The danger of mega-partisan identity is that it encourages citizens to care more about partisan victory than about real policy outcomes. We find ways to justify almost any governmental policy as long as it is the policy of our own team. What is best for America, Americans or even small children is secondary to whether our party’s team gets what it demanded.”

But it’s for the party, so … yea? What’s good for the party is good for all, right?

Is it any wonder so many people don’t want any part of it?

The cephalopods really don’t want anything to do with the whole mess.
GIF found on giphy.

31 thoughts on “Independent thoughts (I’m no party animal)

  1. I’ve been fascinated by how parties change. A few decades ago, Southern Democrats were largely white racists, but now those same people are Republicans. Their attitudes haven’t changed, just their party affiliation.

    Or, let’s list all the political similarities between Republicans Abraham Lincoln and Donald Trump. Okay, that’s enough.

    Like

  2. You Vill Do Vhat You Are Told? Yah Wohl! Fraulein Fuhrer! He said mechanically–like a robot with no independent programming.

    Like

  3. I do not like when people make automatic, knee jerk, reflexive comments or responses which indicate that they are not thinking or even trying to think about what they are saying. It seems as if they just want you to Shut Up because you are challenging what they think and believe in. Their minds are like You-Know-Who (the former sister-in-law) as in their minds are made up and they do not want to be confused with the facts.

    Like

  4. As for eating at Chick-Fil-A, I like their waffle fries. However, since I am allergic to pickles, I usually remove the pickles from my sandwich on the rare occasions when I indulge myself by eating there.

    Like

    • Have to admit I usually just go to Corky’s. I don’t like eating alone in restaurants, and don’t have the patience to wait overload for takeout.

      I’ve heard Margo’s and Grampa’s are good. At some point I’ll try Eat My Catfish.

      Like

  5. When the members of the opposite of Progress in Pound Laundry refuse to negotiate, I don’t get paid for helping to take care of my fellow veterans.

    Like

  6. Since I am an independent thinker, it is safe to continue to communicate with me. I am not a party animal unless someone offers myself and my musician friends lots of money to come and entertain at their party. Another reason it is safe to continue to communicate with me is that I am not a politician or a used car salesman.

    Like

  7. Chocolate? Did you say Chocolate? I will be glad to volunteer to help you eat the chocolate. I will even eat the ones with nougat and/or crickets in it for you (said the confirmed chocoholic). Since I am allergic to orange, lemon, coconut, pecans, and almonds, I will be glad to let you eat them if you will let me have the rest of the chocolate.

    Like

  8. I cannot remember the name of the professor in a political science course which I took at the University of Absolutely Last Resort here but I do remember that this man encouraged and supported debate in his class. It was one of the most interesting classes I took in college.

    Like

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.