Smears to you

Just coming forward is brave.
Photo of Dr. Christine Blasey Ford by Getty Pool Images found on Esquire.

It’s been horrifying to watch the piranhas’ frenzy after Dr. Christine Blasey Ford came forward with her allegations about Judge Brett Kavanaugh. There are many reasons those who have been sexually assaulted or harassed don’t come forward, as the attacks perpetuated against Ford amply demonstrate.

I’m younger than Ford, but still in her generation, and I know well the usual reaction to such allegations. My mom, in her 70s, attests that it was much the same in her day (not that her day is over). I’m sure if my grandmothers were still alive, they’d say the same, if not worse.

Because baggy jeans and a sweatshirt obviously say, “Come and get me.”
Image found on Side B Magazine.

Women (and some men as well) don’t talk about assaults because, among other reasons, to do that they’d have to relive them. They would have to deal with the insinuation or outright accusation that they were to blame for the assault because of what they were wearing or drinking, who they associated with, or any other reason to blame anyone but the person actually responsible (because he’s a good boy/man, and we can’t ruin his life). Most women don’t want to put themselves through that. That’s why it’s believed only about 40 percent—if that—of sexual assaults are ever reported to the police. And filing a false report to get back at someone? It doesn’t happen nearly as often as some seem to think, and can lead to serious legal ramifications. Even when an assault is reported, it doesn’t mean that anything will come of it—sometimes the reports aren’t taken seriously by police, and more often than not, the perpetrator likely won’t be punished.

And you know someone will.
Image found on Shaping Youth.

I’m not passing judgment on whether Dr. Ford’s allegations are true or false, but they deserve investigation. What they don’t deserve are death threats to her and her family, and the outrageous smears floating around that have been debunked (no, that’s not a semi-nude Ford passed out on a picnic table … or with George Soros … or holding a “Not my president” sign). I’ve seen a few similar smears against Kavanaugh (also debunked), and he doesn’t deserve that either.

But that’s what we’ve come to now: If you don’t agree with someone, just smear ’em. Facts don’t matter; scurrilous stories do. What’s worse is that the reaction to reports of sexual misconduct seems to depend on partisan affiliation. As a recent New York Times editorial noted, though, sexual assault is not partisan. Offenders and victims can come from either side of the aisle.

And as our own Arkansas Democrat-Gazette editorial staff wrote in a Tuesday editorial: “If there’s one thing this entire process has taught us, it should be the importance of listening. That doesn’t mean an automatic guilty verdict for people accused of such heinous acts. It just means listening to both the victim and accuser.”

This applies to entirely too many people, and most stay silent.
Image found on Medium.

That means listening without preconceived notions, a difficult ask nowadays when where you stand politically (or where people believe you stand … because no one can possibly have a range of views) determines how much weight some listeners will give your allegations. But believe me, you can be as disgusted by Harvey Weinstein as you are by Tim Murphy, or by Dennis Hastert as much as you are by Anthony Weiner. Frankly, I’m disgusted by all of them.

Survivors of sexual assault come from all walks of life. Randi Weingarten, president of the American Federation of teachers, is one.
Image found on AFT Voices.

Back when the Stormy Daniels story was blowing up, FiveThirtyEight did a comparison of polls regarding sex scandals, and the results were illuminating. In a 1998 CBS poll, the Monica Lewinsky-Bill Clinton affair was deemed a private matter dealing with Clinton’s personal life by 77 percent of Democrats polled, while 64 percent of Republicans polled believed it was a public matter. Gallup asked the same year if it mattered to evaluations of presidential candidates if a candidate had an extramarital affair; 55 percent of Republicans said yes, while only 16 percent of Democrats did.

Twenty years later, a Huffington Post/YouGov survey found that 67 percent of Republicans (as opposed to 26 percent of Democrats) believed “an elected official who has committed an immoral act in their personal life can still behave ethically and fulfill their duties in their public and professional life.”

Sexual misconduct has no party.
Image found on Time.

So obviously, whether an official is Republican or Democratic matters even when that official can’t keep his hands to himself.

This is why I have a bruise on my forehead and a dent in my desk.

There is no easy solution to the problem of sexual misconduct, and as long as we treat the accused and the victim not on the merits of their stories alone but on their partisan leanings, religious beliefs, occupation, or any other thing that has nothing to do with the event in question, we’ll keep running into the same issues. A creep is a creep, period.

Fear keeps so many from reporting their sexual assaults. This Twitter thread illustrates some of the reasons.
Image found on Women’s Health.

Memory is a funny thing, and traumatic events—sexual assault, shootings, bombings, tornadoes, for example—can leave holes; here I speak from my own experience as well as that of others. For some every detail is burned into the psyche, while for others smells, sounds, sights and tactile sensations may linger while exact times and dates don’t. What we don’t forget, though, whether (in the case of sexual misconduct) it was just an attempt or a full-fledged assault, is how we felt, and sometimes still do: small, terrified, guilt-ridden, depressed, angry, ashamed, in denial. (I recommend to male readers that they read Monica Hesse’s Washington Post column on what women don’t tell their dads, and why.)

Some of us aren’t brave enough to face the gantlet so many have recently run. All of us just want peace. And justice would be good too.

Sooner or later, there will be justice.
Image found on Business Insider.

17 thoughts on “Smears to you

  1. There are so many things wrong with the way Dr. Ford’s accusations have been handled. One that hasn’t been highlighted enough is the Republican explanation–often from Republican women–that “All high school boys behaved that way, sexually molesting girls.”

    For the record, I didn’t. I didn’t know anyone who did. This is not to deny that it ever happened, but it was not a universal rite of passage for all boys. I would guess that the majority of us were NOT the moral degenerates now given a pass by Republicans.

    But here’s my point. Kavanaugh swears (under oath) that he didn’t do it, while his “supporters” seem to be calling him a liar when they insist that ALL boys did it. Can’t have it both ways.

    Like

    • Good point.
      I only know of a couple of boys in my class who acted like that. It certainly wasn’t all of them.
      I think Kavanaugh’s histrionics alone are enough to disqualify him. I have no confidence he can be impartial.

      Like

      • I agree on his histrionics. If he were a woman, everyone would assume she was in her “time of the month” and, therefore, shouldn’t be trusted on the Supreme Court. Given his gender, we can only fall back on the assertions that he was a belligerent drunk in his youth. His belligerent behavior in his “rebuttal” made me wonder if he had a couple of brewskis at lunch.

        Like

  2. What type of role model was Brett Kavanaugh’s father, Edward E. Kavanaugh? Was he a good man who tried to teach his son to treat women with respect? Or did Brett Kavanaugh reject his father’s example? My late father was a good man in some ways. He did try to teach me to be nice to the women–all of the women and treat them with respect. However, in some ways, he did behave as if he was God’s Gift To Women although my father did not believe and did not attend church. He was an atheist or an agnostic of some type. For a lot of men, their primary role model is their father–if they have a father involved in their lives. Some boys do grow up in single parent homes with no male role model or models in their lives.

    Like

  3. I seem to remember reading somewhere that Fred and Mary Trump did a lot of charity work but I guess their son does not want to follow their example. Also, I remember reading that one of Donald Trump’s role models was the late George Steinbrenner.

    Like

  4. I have heard some stories about sexual harassment from the women in my family. That would include my mother, my aunt, my sisters, my nieces, and my ex-wife.

    Like

  5. Also, unlike too many men, I have noticed that women seem to like it when I try to behave like a gentleman and treat them with respect.

    Like

  6. I know what verbal harassment feels like. Approximately twenty years ago when I was in my thirties and still working in the hospital kitchen, one of the women who also worked in the kitchen made me an offer she thought I couldn’t refuse and I said “NO”.

    Like

  7. “I think Kavanaugh’s histrionics alone are enough to disqualify him. I have no confidence he can be impartial.” Not to mention lying under oath about what the stuff in his yearbook meant and dissembling about his drinking. His testimony alone was more than enough to disqualify him. And I was left wondering if he still drinks heavily.

    That aside, how do we find our way back from today’s widespread partisan hate and distrust?

    Like

Leave a reply to Laurence Gray Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.