Fear still a factor

The images of that day are still fresh in my mind. Image found on Wikimedia Commons.

Twenty-three years ago today, I stood in the newsroom with about 15 to 20 others watching the three TVs near the city editors’ desks. None of us there that early in the morning, mostly features and a few news staff members, could really fathom what we were seeing.

Some of us went to the TVs at the first report across the wire of a plane striking one of the towers of the World Trade Center, thinking it had to have been a horrible accident. The second plane erased that thought entirely.

Our world would never be the same.

While allies quickly came to our aid, a new wave of Islamophobia was unleashed that never quite went away. There had been waves before, including after a previous terror plot on the World Trade Center, and the Oklahoma City bombing (which was initially blamed on Muslim terrorism), but it wasn’t really till 9/11 that it gained a name.

“Othering” people is just another way to divide, usually used by those in power to keep certain segments from gaining power. Image found on Human Rights Watch.

Dalia Mogahed, a scholar at the Institute for Social Policy and Understanding and former executive director of the Gallup Center for Muslim Studies, spoke to the Othering and Belonging Institute at UC Berkeley about the effects of Islamophobia on democracy, saying it affects it in at least three ways.

“First, the anti-Sharia legislation. The anti-Sharia legislation is really part of a larger problem,” she said, “as the same lawmakers that are targeting Muslims are targeting other minorities as well, and what the legislation does is it restricts people’s rights, and fosters a political climate that makes it easier to restrict those rights. With that, the rights of Muslim Americans are then restricted and the rights of other minorities are also restricted, and Islamophobia creates the political climate to make that possible, thus affecting democracy.

“Secondly, Islamophobia hurts our democracy in that it scares people, as Islamophobia is fueled by fear. Fear makes people more accepting of authoritarianism, conformity, and prejudice, and those three things undermine democratic principles, and it makes people less likely to dissent, to speak out, and to hold their government accountable. And thirdly, it manipulates people, and manipulates the public to consent to policies that they would otherwise not agree to.”

I have no desire to live in a nation governed by anyone like authoritarians Vladimir Putin or Jinping Xi (or anyone who admires them). Image found on Stanford University.

Islamophobia is still a factor in the U.S., but other fears have outpaced it in recent years, which has led us to where we are now, a nation led by fear and in danger of falling further in thrall to authoritarianism.

To those who pooh-pooh that idea, I offer up the recent efforts to curb rights of bodily autonomy, as well as attacks on libraries, among other things. As loath I am to invoke slippery-slope arguments, we do seem to be on that slippery slope as we speak, with actions to ban abortion by trying to convince people that abortions are being done willy-nilly up to the point of birth (which is ludicrous, especially considering that the health of the mother, both current and future, is the prime consideration for those late in pregnancy; if she dies or is rendered infertile by the continuation of a nonviable pregnancy, there won’t be future babies). Meanwhile, in vitro fertilization is caught in the riptide, thanks to a court ruling in Alabama that gave stored embryos the same legal protection afforded to children.

Medical professionals can oversee doctors and their relations with patients, but when the layman government gets in the middle, that can go too far (and lead to nonsense like “preborn baby” replacing “fetus” in official medical charts). Illustration by John Deering.

Efforts to limit gender-affirming care (typically based on a less than full understanding of what goes into gender transition, which takes years of medical and mental care before it even gets to the point of surgery; I mean, seriously, a certain candidate is suggesting schools are performing surgeries without parents’ knowledge) could similarly start to affect hormone and other therapy for cis people. Hormones for menopausal women, erectile-dysfunction drugs, plastic surgery … that could all believably be considered gender-affirming care.

No one wants a Wild West-style approach on either of these, but that they should be left mostly to doctors, with appropriate oversight (meaning medical professionals, not legislators). Keeping medical procedures legal and safe (that’s what that oversight is for) should be the aim, not making political points, especially by lying for the purpose of sowing division.

I spent a lot of time in our school libraries (worked at the high school one), and at the libraries in Greenwood and Fort Smith when I was a kid. My mom still went to the Greenwood library at least every few months in the last years before she died. Image found on Rogers Public Library.

Fear, as Mogahed noted, is what we should be guarding against, not our fellow citizens. Fear divides us and makes it easier for those with less-than-noble aims to take advantage. They’re able to do this because they fool people into believing simplistic scenarios, such as the idea that librarians are grooming kids, that ignore nuance and truth. (Hey, the librarians I know are only interested in grooming kids to be lifelong readers.)

They don’t want you to grasp the common-sense reality that libraries already have rules and procedures in place to determine age-appropriateness of material, and separate sections, but instead want you to believe that books intended for teens and adults are shelved right beside copies of “The Velveteen Rabbit.” Even libraries with limited space separate sections, but legislators can make it more onerous, as those in Idaho did this year, forcing one small library to announce it would become “adults only” in July to avoid the possibility of breaking the law since it had no physical barriers between sections. It was able later to walk that back by using parent waivers for children, but it shouldn’t have had to make such plans in the first place since its procedures were already working.

They don’t want you to see that medical procedures, no matter what they are, should be between doctor and patient, with the safety of those procedures overseen by medical licensing boards.

And they really don’t want you to understand that if others’ hard-won rights are lost and you do nothing, your rights might be next. We need laws, but when the aim is not to ensure safety or equal protection but to make us fear and keep a segment of the population under onerous rule, we should question why.

Vote. It matters.

Don’t piss this cat off further by believing the lies you’re told about fellow citizens. Image found on reddit.

9 thoughts on “Fear still a factor

  1. I couldn’t watch the debate but have been reading a lot this morning. I especially loved Trump repeating the myth about immigrants eating people’s pets. When a moderator corrected him, saying it was not true, Trump evidently justified his claim by saying he saw it on TV.

    To substantiate Trump’s claim, I offer the following list of people whose pets have been eaten by immigrants:

    __________________________

    __________________________

    __________________________

    Liked by 4 people

  2. We’ve got to somehow shut down the influx of illegal aliens rushing across our borders from 165 countries (per Trump @ debate 2024). Next thing we know, the other 29 countries left might get the same idea. We’ll wake up one morning and people will be hanging over the borders, trying their best to hold unto as much red, white and blue as they can.

    Liked by 3 people

  3. On September 11, 2001, I was planning to drive to Joplin, Missouri to visit with my aunt (my father’s sister). I left my house in North Little Rock just about the same time the first airplane flew into the World Trade Center. Since I was listening to music on my car’s CD player instead of the radio, I didn’t know what was happening in New York City and Washington, D.C. until after I arrived at my aunt’s place near Joplin.

    Like

  4. I thought it was the responsibility of parents to keep track of and supervise what their children are reading instead of libraries and librarians? However, according to someone (not to mention any names) who apparently fancies themselves to be an expert on this subject, I don’t know what the Hell I am talking about because I don’t have any children of my own. Since I also like cats but don’t have any as pets right now, does that qualify me to be a “childless cat-person”?

    Like

  5. It is a very dangerous world out there. I’m struck by how much in a protective psychological bubble we Americans are. 9/11 killed one in 100,000. 2 in 100,000 died in the Pearl Harbor attack. Your chances of dying in a car accident are 1 in 93.

    Liked by 2 people

Leave a reply to fauxcelt Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.